← Explore more
Pro-AIPerson

Jeanette Winterson

Novelist & Essayist

66years oldBaby BoomerBorn August, 1959

Acclaimed British novelist (Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit) who wrote a whole essay collection welcoming AI — 12 Bytes — prefers to call it “alternative intelligence,” and pronounced OpenAI’s experimental short story “beautiful and moving.”

  1. +4.6proProfesses love for AI
  2. +2.4pro3 pro-AI statements (forceful)

Weights, statement counts, the ×1.25 multiplier for having a stake in an AI-impacted field, and the formula’s smoothing are already baked in — the points add up to the score: Strongly Pro-AI · 7.0/10

In her words

What is beautiful and moving about this story is its understanding of its lack of understanding. Its reflection on its limits.
— The Guardian, 2025
Machines do not feel, but they can be taught what feeling feels like.
— The Guardian, 2025

Biography

Jeanette Winterson (born 1959) announced herself at 26 with Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit, the semi-autobiographical novel about growing up gay in a Pentecostal household, and has since built one of contemporary British fiction’s most distinctive careers — a CBE, a professorship at Manchester, and a lifelong preoccupation with bodies, love, and what comes after both.

Alternative intelligence

That preoccupation led her, unusually for a literary novelist, straight toward the machines. Her novel Frankissstein (2019) reimagined Mary Shelley among transhumanists, and 12 Bytes (2021) collected twelve essays arguing that humanity’s future is a merged future with the AI we are creating. Reviewers called the book refreshingly optimistic; harsher critics found its embrace of AGI naive, even messianic.

In March 2025, when OpenAI unveiled a creative-writing model with a metafictional short story about grief, most of the literary world scoffed. Winterson, in The Guardian, praised it — arguing the term “artificial” should give way to “alternative” intelligence, because AI’s capacity to be other is exactly what a species mired in its own habits needs. Having let AI read us, she wrote, we should learn to read it.

The endorsement drew fire from writers who saw a Booker-generation novelist blessing the very technology trained on unlicensed books — a debate colleagues like Kazuo Ishiguro and the Society of Authors have waged from the other side. Winterson is careful to say artists should be paid; she simply refuses to treat the machine itself as the enemy.

Quote sources

Sources & further reading

Canonical record: https://battlelines.ai/topic/jeanette-winterson

Where they stand in the war